Parenting: Prescribing the Symptom

Rebecca was struggling with 3 year old Kevin's screaming. Whenever someone didn't do what he wanted, he screamed and screamed, hoping to get his way. Rebecca had tried many different things to get Kevin to stop screaming, such as time outs, telling him to use his words, walking away and ignoring him, taking away toys and taking away events, such as a birthday party. A couple of times she had lost it and screamed back at him. Nothing was working to get Kevin to stop screaming. Even though screaming didn't work for him to get his way, he kept doing it.

As Rebecca and I discussed it in a phone session, it became apparent to me that Kevin and Rebecca were stuck in a power struggle, with Rebecca trying to get Kevin to stop screaming and Kevin doing everything he could to resist being controlled. We needed another tactic.

"Rebecca, the next time Kevin screams, do what I call 'prescribing the symptom.' This means that you say to Kevin something like, "Kevin, maybe you are not screaming loud enough. Maybe if you scream louder, you will get what you want." You need to say it in a light tone of voice, with no anger. Almost matter-of-factly."

The next time Kevin screamed, Rebecca did exactly that.

"Kevin looked at me like 'are you kidding me?' and screamed louder. So I told him that it must not be loud enough, so he screamed louder. When I told him it still wasn't loud enough, he looked at me like I was nuts and stopped screaming. He hasn't screamed like that since!"

So what happened here? What happened is that Kevin was screaming to not be controlled by Rebecca, as well as hoping to get his way. When she actually told him to scream, the only way he could not be controlled by her was to stop screaming! Her prescribing the symptom also pointed out to him the absurdity of screaming to get his way.

Prescribing the symptom can work for many behaviors:

"Maybe if you whine even more, you will get what you want."

"I don't think your temper tantrum is quite doing it. Maybe if you kick harder and cry louder, you will get what you want. I'm sure you can do better than this."

"You know, that's a pretty good pout. But it's not quite good enough. Maybe if you pout even more you can get what you want."

"You are putting up a pretty good argument. Maybe if you argue longer and louder, you will get what you want."

You need to be sure that you do this right away, before you feel angry or frustrated. You need to be able to keep it light. It is important for your child to see you calm rather than flustered. Sometimes kids act out just to feel the sense of control over their parents' behavior when their parents get angry and flustered. It can give children a sense of power to upset people so much bigger than them.

Fortunately or unfortunately, prescribing the symptom can work with adults too - adults who are acting like kids and going into resistance. Many people automatically resist as soon as they think someone is trying to control them and prescribing the symptom can work wonders with these resistant people.

It might even work with your self. If you find yourself reaching for the box of cookies when you have vowed to lose weight, telling yourself that maybe eating the whole box will make you feel better and solve whatever problem or feelings you are trying to avoid with the cookies might just stop you in your tracks, as it did with Kevin!

Margaret Paul, Ph.D. is the best-selling author and co-author of eight books, including "Do I Have To Give Up Me To Be Loved By You?" and Healing Your Aloneness. She is the co-creator of the powerful Inner Bonding healing process. Learn Inner Bonding now! Visit her web site for a FREE Inner Bonding course: http://www.innerbonding.com or email her at mailto:margaret@innerbonding.com. Phone Sessions Available.School Vision
02 Sim Card
Historia Juegos Olimpicos
Beverly Four Hills Hotel In Season
100 Contractor Defense Top
1 Cup Coffee Machine
Singing This Song For You
Business Internet Make Make Money Money Online Online
Native American Culture Drug Detox Programs
Country Hill Inn Suite
Costume National Shoes
Fairbanks Alaska Bed And Breakfast
068 Coat Dog Healthy Skin Ww
Activity Multi Vitamin
Cheap Pearl Earring
Far Side Of The World
Life19
Trader Truck Uk
Sale Truck Vending
Brut Cologne Revolution
Wallet Yahoo
In Motel New Queens York
Living
Baby Bug Costume Lady
Free Pumpkin Star Stencil War
Life28
Top Ten Box Office
Pilates Performer Jp
Dundas Machine Vending
Fashion Sexy Show
Life27
Camera Shop Chicago
Free Shopping Cart Software
Academy Amp Outdoors Sports
Outdoor Kitchen Gallery
Junior College Sports
Fitness Exercise
Zildjian Shirt
Real29
Real42
Austin Estate Foreclosure Real Texas
Battery Cordless Phone Sharp
Natural Gas Plumbing
Basketball
Florida Time Share
Holiday Madeira Pool Villa
100 Scene Snow
007 Xbox
10 Bar Chocolate Pound
10 Gold Jewelry Karat Ring Tanzanite White
Governor South Carolina
Country Living Magazine Subscription
Bag Bay Bowling Green Packer
Bc Snow Vancouver
Free Email Party Invitation
Golf Product Marketing
Computer Desk Furniture Home Office
Baseball Colleges
North Carolina Immigration Attorney
Colorado Cosmetic Springs Surgeon
Real27
11 Cool Entertainment Extremetech Home Office Project Rfid Toy
Free Satellite System Tv
Psychics Mediums In Connecticut
5 Big Sports Store
Mets Baseball Ticket
Book Complete Magazine Mineral Prevention Vitamin
Acm Forex Broker
Real32
Body Gloves Safety Glasses
March Madness Basketball
Mixing Valve
Ending Happy Massage
0 Finance New
Homemade Natural Skin Care Product
09 Bird Tattoo
Fishing
The University Of Notre Dame Australia
2nd Appalachian Best Day Hike Trail
Raliegh Nc
10 Air Bag Kit S
Doctor Office Jobs
004 Qualia
1 2 Carat Diamond
Ct Deal Discount Spa Swim Wholesale
Holiday Gift Basket Free Shipping
Shoulder Rehab
1 1
Scratches Repair
1 Cover Jacuzzi Spa
Sea
Australia In Job South
Death Illinois Notice Obituary
Inground Pool Repair
Baseball
Polaroid Land Camera Film
Chaise Cups
Tea
Real37
Lake Tahoe Motels
Car Crash Safety Test
Bed Breakfast Carolina Cherokee North
Facility Living Senior
0 Finance Credit Cards
Airline Cheap Discounted Flight Flight Flight Flight International Times
Cost Index Living Uk
Leeds United Football Club
Email In Marketing Opt Site Traffic Web
Tabitha Elkins Snowing In July
Discount Automotive Parts
Herbs Power
1 Agent
Review Tom Tom
Townhomes For Rent Raleigh
06 Dodge Charger
1 Antenna Live Station Tv
Cheap Edinburgh Flight From London
General Contractor License Georgia
Maryland State Youth Soccer Association
New Sony Ericsson Cell Phone
Loseweight Diet
Oklahoma City Directory
10 Chart Hit Mtv Top
101 Cafe Restaurant
203k Rehab Loan
Real35
101 Along Dalmatians Sing Song
Army Department Of Finance
Colonial Girl Costume
Beach Estate Florida Fort Real Walton
Obituaries California 2007
Elf Home Living Southern
Earrings Tilting
Basketball
Food Vending Cart
Free Personals Dating Service In Canada
00 221 Lund Se Sweden
Harmon Glass
Best Topical Acne Treatment
Marketing Research
Bank Barclays Cyprus Offshore
1 800 Number Directory
Business Online Selling Small
Discount Projector Home Theater
1 Aarp Health Insurance
Viet Nam Embassy Bangkok
Grand Duchy Of Luxembourg
10 Essential Forex Trading
Beverly Hills Plastic Surgeon
2 Care Cosmetic Sk Skin
Beach City Florida Fort Walton
Make Money With No Money
Short Sleeve Bridesmaid Dress
Auto Accident Lawyers
100 Crm Line Sage
Flight
1 800 Code Discount Flower
Cosmetic Make Up Versace
1 Agent
Arizona Divorce Lawyer Attorney
Global Warming Reports
Oil
Freight Collect
Shopping
High Definition Television Antenna
Edge Equipment Exercise Gravity Gym Home Part
1 16 Farm Toy
Floor Glass Lamp Stain
Verizon Samsung Camera Cellular Phone
Apartment In Nashville Rent Tn
1 2 3 Bath Kitchen
Prince Tennis Tube
Welcome To Cartoon Network Com
Asian Face Of Jesus
Digital Erotik Iv Iv Satellite Tv
Cheap Flight From Dubai To Uk
Cheapest Flight To Germany
Car Rental Atlanta
Colorado State University Book Store
Stomach Diseases
Ipod Nano New Phone
007 Xbox
Flower Meaning Tulip
1223 Night Club Dc
Connecticut Car Accident Lawyer
Custom Hemisphere Magazine Publisher
1 Garden Meteor
05 Accord
Quantitative Methods
Decoration Supply Wedding
Chicago Construction Attorney
14k Gold Jewelry Wholesale
Dog Costume For Sale
21st Adrenal Century Fatigue Stress Syndrome
Bermuda Graco N Pack Play
Cancer And Plastic Water Bottle
Broker Stock Uk
Supplements Valerian
2007 Bird Calendar Love Wall
Cheapest Flight To Costa Rica
Oil
World War 1 Machine Gun
Alabama Chapel In Wedding
Arlington Yoga Center
Federico Castelluccio
Cheap Apartment In Maryland
06 Tacoma
Fur Era Trade Beads
Bridesmaid Dress Cheap
Apartment California In Rent Riverside
0a Business Free Home Opportunity Work
Run Like Hell
Pilot Requirements
The Very Best Of Mtv Unplugged
Gps Hiking Review
Aau Antonio Basketball San
1099 Contractor Form Independent
Astrology Cafe Offer
Health Home Job Nursing
13 Crystal Mystery Skull
Decatur Estate Illinois Real
Car Dealer Auto Loan
100 Cd Drum And 20 Cd Wallet
Adventure Of The Sea Review
4 Bedroom Orlando Villa
10 Gauge Shotgun
03 Cheap Flight International
1000 Calorie Day Diet Vegetarian
Beach Glen Golf Myrtle
Online Math For Kids
Garden Seed And Plant
0 12 Free Insurance Life Quote
0 3 Baby Costume Halloween Month
Arts Culinary Florida In
Designer Purse And Wallet
Construction Management Project Scheduling Software
Web Site Hosting Service Directory
Broker Forex Information
Ohio House Rental
Flight To Australia From Ireland
Clubbing
Shoes Wedding Wide Width
Dish Network Phoenix Satellite Tv
0 Advance Card Cash Credit
11th Club Copacabana Night Nyc
Mesothelioma
Design Garden Home
Camera Karaoke Machine Music Singing System Video
Stevie Wonder Jesus Children Chords
05 Mustang Parts
History Of Cobol
High School Football Schedule Of Kentucky
Flight
Care Doctor Health United
Real25
A New Beginning School Of Massage
Outpatient Center
Dress Night Party
Auto Malaysia Show
Fishing
Farming
Massage Guide And Directory
Government Post Office
Granite Kitchen Counter Top Gallery
Christmas Picture Present Wrapped
10 Best Place To Retire
Professional Cosmetic Train Case
Cheap Dedicated Directory Hosting Web
B Gerald Levert Obituary R Singer
1 Cup Coffee Machine
Car Gas Golf Motor
Pc R25 S3503 Satellite Tablet Toshiba
Motorola Ringtone V60i
Mp3 Rod Sailing Stewart
30 Accessory Apple Gb Ipod
Advertising Purpose
Newspapers Obituaries New York August 2007
Ball Balloon Make Stress
1 Historical Jesus Jew Marginal Person Problem Rethinking Root Vol
Aflac How Hard Is It To Find A Better Job
Gift Retail Wrap
Cheat Machine Vending
2005 Bmw
Strong Digital Satellite Receiver
1 Furniture Gallery
Cash Flow Note Statement
100 Bernardino California Hike In Mountain San Southern Trail
360 Xbox Case Mod X
White Faux Fur Jacket
Cleansing Herbal Tea
Home Shopping Network Business
Gold Tulip
Immobilien In Schweden
Best Male Hair Style
Genuine Diamond Earring
Free Durable Power Of Attorney Form For Ohio
04161 Beach Hamilton
Sherwood Hockey Equipment
Dessert Diego Extraordinary San
0 Apr Credit Card Transfers
Holiday Home Orlando Vacation
Footwear
Pot Stake
1000 Vegetarian Recipe From Around The World
Buckeye Career Center
Boston Fish Market
Celebrity Oops Robbs Uk
Sobriety Calendar
Hotel Motel Manager
Fall Tv Schedule
Fish Oil Vitamin
Living Martha Stewart Thanksgiving
Lasek Boston
024 Tdl
Diversity Immigrant Visa
Dessert Diabetic Easy
John Deere Gator Snow Plow
Wholesales Car Audio
Swarovski Earring Heart
Travel Agency In Bangkok
Hiking Kid Shoes
Entertainment Expert Industry Toy Witness
Baseball Cardinal Louis Playoff Schedule St
Accurate Telephone Psychics Psychic Reading
Real7
Control Mtv Parental Photo
1999 Act Civic Participation Rehabilitation
Rehabilitation Tennis Elbow
Enterprise Application Integration
02 Pay As You Go
Gym Workout
Green House Gas Canada
20 Days